Cover art for the Wind Cave National Park episode.

Wind Cave National Park | What's hiding under a field of grass?

· 21 min · Wind Cave National Park, Custer County, South Dakota, USA

Listen now on: Apple Podcasts Spotify YouTube RSS.com

Summary

A short written summary of the episode — not the full transcript. Press play above for the whole thing.

In 1881, two brothers were hunting rabbits in the Black Hills when they heard wind coming out of a hole the size of a sheet of paper. The hole is Wind Cave. One leaned over and the wind took his hat. He came back with his family and threw the hat at the hole; this time the cave pulled it in. Nobody has found it since.

The hole breathes because the cave and the sky trade air. A storm makes the outside air lighter and the cave pushes out; when the weather settles, heavier air pushes back. Underground it is 54 degrees all year, because the rock holds the average like a blanket.

The Lakota call this door Oniya Oshoka, where the earth breathes inside, and Maka Oniye, breathing earth. In the park’s recording of the Oglala Lakota emergence account — told by the late Wilmer Mesteth, retold by ranger Sina Bear Eagle — the first people came up through this passage, stopped four times to rest and pray, and followed a bison hoofprint. The creator shrank the hole behind them so they would remember where they came from. Big asked how anyone gets back in. They don’t. This world is the next part of the journey.

In 1868 the United States set the Black Hills aside for the Sioux Nation’s “absolute and undisturbed use.” In 1877 Congress took the land anyway. The treaty required three of every four adult men to agree, and about one in ten signed. In 1980 the Supreme Court ruled the taking violated the Fifth Amendment and the nations were owed money. They have never touched it. Taking it would mean agreeing the hills were for sale.

A teenager mapped the cave by candlelight. Alvin McDonald tied a string at the entrance and went down with paper and pencil. On January 23, 1891, after nine hours, he wrote in his diary that he had “given up the idea of finding the end of Wind Cave.” In February he went down 33 times. He died of typhoid at 20.

The tour passes boxwork, thin calcite fins in a honeycomb where softer rock dissolved away. The park says Wind Cave holds more boxwork than all the other caves on Earth combined. The map holds 167 miles, and rangers think that is a tenth of the cave.

Five hundred feet below the grass, the passages reach lakes holding some of the cleanest water on Earth. There are no fish or bugs, only bacteria — 350 kinds, many found nowhere else, some living on metal in the rock. Little wanted to know whether anything lived in it. NASA funded a robot to study those lakes as practice for Europa.

Back above ground, in 1889 William Hornaday counted 1,091 left in North America. In 1913, 14 rode a train from the Bronx Zoo to South Dakota, and their descendants started herds in 16 states and Mexico.

We sat in the parking lot with the same view: grass to the horizon. The episode leaves the kids a challenge: ask a grown-up what they see. You have the newest eyes in the family. A rancher sees a field, a geologist sees the most complex cave on Earth, a Lakota family sees the door their people came through. Same spot. Nobody is wrong.

Show notes and links

The place

Wind Cave National Park — One of the longest caves on Earth under the largest natural mixed-grass prairie in the park system, in the Black Hills of South Dakota.

Who helped

  • Sina Bear EagleWind Cave ranger who retells the Oglala Lakota emergence story in the park's recording
  • Wilmer MestethOglala Lakota tribal historian and spiritual leader, whose telling of the emergence story the park recorded