Red crossbill

A stocky finch with a bill whose tips cross, built to lever open conifer cones. At Bryce it works the ponderosa belt and the spruce at the top.

Red crossbill at a glance

Loxia curvirostra LOX-ee-uh kur-vee-ROSS-truh

Type
Bird · finch
Diet
Herbivore
Size
About the length of a dollar bill (5.5 to 6.5 inches / 14 to 17 cm), with a head that looks too big and a bill that looks broken.
Lifespan
Wild birds are known to live past ten years, though most never get close.
Conservation
Least concern. The species is not declining across its range, but some of its call types are small and local enough to worry about.

Eats conifer seeds, buds, insects

It wedges the crossed tips of its bill under a cone scale and bites down, levering the scale up to reach the seed. It is so tied to conifer seed that it feeds seed to its nestlings instead of insects.

Should you worry?

Nothing to worry about. It is a seed eater with no interest in people, and the worst it does is fly off.

A flock of red crossbills moves through a stand of ponderosa pine like one animal with thirty bodies. NPS describes them foraging in flocks, moving in unison from tree to tree, and in the morning dropping to the ground to pick seed out of the litter. Then the trees go quiet and the flock is somewhere else.

The bill is the whole story. The tips cross when the bill is closed: one mandible swings past the other, so the two tips pass each other instead of meeting. To feed, the bird wedges the slightly open tips under a cone scale and bites down, and the crossed tips lever the scale up and hold it while the tongue takes the seed.

That is a tool for reaching food nothing else can get at, and the bird is so dependent on conifer seed that it feeds seed to its nestlings instead of insects. Which means it can nest whenever it finds a heavy cone crop, even in the middle of winter, because the one thing a nestling needs is already on the tree.

Crossbills are also restless. NPS records eruptions of crossbills every few years in late summer that last through the winter, when the birds leave one forest for another with more cones. Some years Bryce is loud with them and some years it is not, which is true of most of the good birds.

At Bryce, look in the mature conifers. Ponderosa pine and manzanita dominate the middle elevations, and white fir, spruce and aspen take the top of the plateau, so both ends of the road are cone country. Watch for a stocky finch with a heavy head and a bill that looks put on crooked. The male is brick red; the female is yellowish below and brownish or olive above. Then keep watching until the bill goes to work on a cone, and the whole adaptation takes about three seconds to see.

If the flock is on the ground in the morning, picking seed out of fallen cones, they will let you closer than a bird on a branch will. Stand still and they will work their way past your boots.

Did you know?

  • The crossed bill is a lever. The tips pass each other instead of meeting, so the bird can jam them under a cone scale and pry it up while it takes the seed.
  • Crossbills feed conifer seed to their young instead of insects, which means they can nest whenever there is a heavy cone crop, including in the middle of winter.
  • They do not stay put. NPS records eruptions of crossbills every few years in late summer that last through the winter, as flocks leave one forest for another with more cones.
  • The male is brick red; the female is yellowish below and brownish or olive above. Both look front-heavy, with a thick neck and a bill that appears to be put on crooked.

Common questions

Why is its bill crossed?

The crossed tips work as a lever. The bird slips them under a cone scale and bites down, and the tips pry the scale up so it can reach the seed inside.

Can a crossbill really nest in winter?

Yes. It feeds its young on conifer seed rather than insects, so a heavy cone crop is all it needs. NPS says it can breed any time it finds a significant amount of cones, even midwinter.

Where would we look for one at Bryce Canyon?

In the mature conifers. Ponderosa pine and manzanita dominate the middle elevations, with white fir, spruce and aspen higher up on the plateau, and the Bristlecone Loop at the top runs through the high forest.

Is a crossbill the same as a goldfinch?

No. They are both finches, but a crossbill is bigger and heavier, with that thick crossed bill for opening cones. Goldfinches have straight, pointed bills for picking seeds off plants.

Where it lives

Where we got this